I agree with you Brian. The Tillotson is very adjustable. And some find it a little too much. But the beauty is you can compensate during the day and night for different atmospheric conditions and fine tune it for different tracks. but if you don't want that. Mikuni makes great carbs. I ran them on Haley Davidson for years. Truly a tune and forget carb with great performance.
Just had this conversation with a customer on the phone yesterday on why we use Mikunis over Tillys anymore.
-- Conversation typically goes like this: Caller: "Got a Tilly from "XYZ" and it ran fine when I first got it. Went to the track the next week and it blubbered all around the track so I twisted this needle, then that one, then I twisted a third needle, (sarcasm inserted) and now "XYZ" won't take it back. So I ask what the pop-off pressure is set at....crickets - the guy on the other end of the phone doesn't know because he has no clue what I'm talking about.
I've had this same conversation dozens of times over the years. Tuning a Tilly is not all that difficult but you need some basic understanding of how the carb works to better tune it on the track. There is no "one size fits all" settings for these carbs. If it's set up right at the shop, it'll be very close at the track - small tweaks if any, not handfuls of needle.
I've built my fair share of Tillotsons over the years - from flathead super stocks in the '80s to limiteds to big opens and they're a lot of work to get the drill pattern right and set everything up so that when they leave our shop I am confident that they are the best I can do. We spend a considerable amount of time on the dyno tuning and working on throttling, etc. so that when an engine leaves our shop it is the best that it can be. Then I get a call similar to the one above and it just breaks my heart, because I don't care how good you are, you are not going to diagnose and tune a carb over the telephone with someone who doesn't really understand a Tillotson.
For shear simplicity, the Mikuni is our default carb of choice now -- they really are plug and play and the customer is hard pressed to "un-tune" it, for lack of better words.