You can also mix them for certain track conditions. I have found that 50/50 goat and black sand works well in dusty conditions or on dry slick tracks. The more dry and dusty the track, the more black sand you want and less goat in the mix. the more moisture in the track, the more goat and less black sand you want. Black sand mixed with acrysol works well as a pre race wipe before you hit the track also, and is a great prep to add bite to your tires during the week, it is somewhat of a chameleon prep, you can add it on top of any other prep and it takes on the qualities of that prep and adds more bite to the tire. I have never seen or heard of black sand ever softening a tire before though when used by itself.