they do not compare. you can make the all work . it just about how hard u have to work them and how often you hit it. burris and maxxis would be the tire of choice. the others are purely an experiment. Im sure there are guys who have em figured out , but they also have the others figured out.
Hoosier is hardly cheap. A normal set is around $260-$275.. They are made with a higher mix of natural rubber so it takes a lot less prep to respond. Also because of this they come up to temp a little quicker so you should run little harder compound Hoosier than you would Maxxis or Burris.