I prefer the genuine Bully discs over the aftermarket. The aftermarket are harder - they may last longer and even take some heat abuse better, but my belief is that a well built clutch shouldn't be getting hot.
As far as grooves or not -- I like the grooves for cleaning, but in all honesty, how often do racers pull their clutches apart and clean the grooves? BTW, A Dremel with .040" cut-off wheel will make some quick grooves in a solid friction disc if you really want - just be careful to cut straight and square so the discs do not pull or chip where they are cut.
The solid friction discs do offer more surface area, but I think with our current engine packages, we have plenty of surface area with a 2 disc Bully already. The minimal amount you give up with the grooves isn't noticeable.
Now, here's the oft-overlooked factor that I think is more important than grooves vs non-grooves:
Surface finish (or grind) that the metal discs are ground. Yes, how aggressive the finish is determines a LOT of how your clutch "feels". Less slip, more slip, just the right amount of slip. It will even change, to a much lesser degree, the spring heights that you use.
Take into consideration all of the aftermarket clutches...each one of these clutch guys is selling basically the same product (some asking $100 more than others) with basically a different color anodizing. What else is different? Some things, not a lot. I'll let you buy them all and figure it out on your own.
-----
Thanks and God bless,
Brian Carlson
Carlson Racing Engines
Vector Cut
z
www.CarlsonMotorsports.com
Carlson Motorsports on
Facebook
31 years of service to the karting industry
Linden, IN
765-339-4407
bcarlson@CarlsonMotorsports.com