An animal carb is not gonna flow enough for a Modified flatty, unless it's barely modified from stock. If it's a big cam, big valve, .080 over, which is what a Mod is, an animal carb will be a restrictor for it. If you weren't impressed with a Tilly, you probably had one that was not set up correctly for what your running or the wrong Tilly. Tillotson's will work extremely well for Limited's, Modified's or Opens if done correctly. How modified is your engine? Is a Mikuni better than a Tilly? I'd say no. Both have their advantages, I think having the ability to tune on the fly is an advantage for the Tilly, the slide carb has better fuel control at part throttle but at the HP numbers of a Mod, you will be hammering the throttle off the turn anyway so no advantage for the slide till you get around 40 HP where you may want to drive it off the turn with the throttle, or in other words not going to full throttle right off the turn.