I have the Phantom guide and the chassis clamp on guide, I got spun last night and blew a chain off, I like a lot of slack in my chain though. I was able to roll it back on and finish the race. The only issue I ever had with the sprocket guards is rocks getting jammed between the gear and the guard, I'm debating on switching back to that style as I've been having chain issues during spin outs. I went from 2009 to 2014 without any series drive line failures, I had it happen twice last year and once last night.