When we first started running the Predator class we bought a non-Hemi because that's what our store had. Once we got to the track we heard about the Hemi, and that "they were better", so when our store got some in we bought one. Didn't notice any significant difference between the two - including on the stopwatch.
Now realize that our rules are box stock - original muffler, original airbox, governor hooked up and working. You could run the original fuel tank or a top plate, but now they say original fuel tank only. Drill holes to vent the gas cap, and disconnect the oil sensor. No aftermarket pipe, and not supposed to put a non-Hemi head on a Hemi block (but they haven't actually published a rule stating that).
We happen to have two other Hemi engines because we were going to put another kart together, but they too run about the same lap times as our first two engines. Can't tell any real advantage over a non-Hemi (in completely stock form) so I wouldn't worry about buying another non-Hemi if I needed another engine and that's all the store had in stock.
However, I'm told by guys who claim they can build me an "undetectable modified Predator" that the hot ticket is a Hemi block with a non-Hemi head (but only certain non-Hemi heads - there are several different part numbers)... if your rules allow that then that's probably what you'll need, but your budget class won't stay budget for long...